After reading the scary story about Ricardo Navarro stabbing Svetlana Orlava a few days after his marriage proposal was rejected on Spanish TV show “Patricia’s Daily Show”, there was a mention that this was not the first time something like this happened.
Probably the first time was on The Jenny Jones Show. On 6th March 1995, on an episode called “Same-Sex Secret Crushes”, Scott Amedure, 32 said he was sexually attracted to his neighbour, Jonathan Schmitz, 25, who was present during the taping. During the show, Schmitz was seen to be shaken and embarrassed, said he’s not gay, and nervously laughing.
Scott Amedure

Jonathan Schmitz

Schmitz was lured to the show by the producers who said he had a secret admirer, but they didn’t tell him the gender of the person. Schmitz later claimed that what Amedure said during the show humiliated and angered him. In addition, Schmitz was told that the title of the show was “Secret Admirers”, in fact it was the suggestive “Same Sex Secret Crushes”.
The thing was, Schmitz had a history of mental illness and alcohol/drug abuse. The tape was due to be aired in 2 weeks, but 3 days after the taping, Schmitz bought a shotgun, then went to Amedure’s mobile home, shooting him twice in the chest. He was later sentenced to between 25 and 50 years in prison.
Due to the murder, the episode was never aired, apart from snippets of it on TV newsreports.
Amedure’s family sued the producers of the TV show, and won USD25 million, but the verdict was later overturned.









